Its nothing strange if u fall in love with two people at the same time. And, for sure ull get more attracted to that boi/girl who is more closer to you, who you share everything in your daily basis. But, henry i guess you are in US right? Which place? Does the one closer to u stay in the same place u do or in different state? And. is he/she is in relationship with u already or he/she has another one? Your question seems somewhat vague. But yah it has happened with me too..!!