If we want to find out who is better, they need to play for a team which has bad records. I think if they both go to mediocre team, Manning has better chances of succeeding because he is a complete package. He calls his own plays and he is very accurate, got strong arms and experts also agree he is more technically sound quarterback than Brady (I am NOT saying Brady lacks all this but Manning is better in this regard)

 Brady has 3 rings and COUNTING. One can argue that he has 3 rings because he is in a better team but don't you think a quarterback makes a team better? I know Carson Palmer is also heck of a Quarterback but he is not making his team better because sometime he lacks ability to make quick decision and makes mental mistakes. Brady has tons of confidence and he is quick. Brady is a good decision maker so he will not loose a game for you.

The most important thing is a system and chemistry. Both Quarterbacks have won Super Bowls but still Brady is in better system.

 Just like comparison between Bush Vs Man Mohan Singh…who is more talented? Of course Man Mohan Singh (Indian Prime Minister) but who is in better system (OK Bad example)……

Brady has the edge so Brady is better.

I log off now and see what others have to say