Posted by: khallid August 26, 2007
Indian Idol and Nepalese Irony
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?        
Friends ! I am tired of reading about PRASHANT is good singer, have a good melidious voice, was in top four due to his regional votes etc etc. I would like to give you some of the reasons why PRASHANT deserves to be in top 4. 1. From the very beginning to the start of PIANO round, who choosed him. Thats from Judges. I think noone argue on this. So up to this extent everyone supports he is good enough. 2. From PIANo round, I think everyone is watching the show and I suppose everyone noticed he never got the worse comment compared to others. I found sometime judges comments is very good for him and sometimes average. In everyshow there are two to three contestants has worse comment then him. But the fact is that the person who has worse comment got more votes and found to be stayed in the show and the person who got best comments was voted out. Why the person of worst comment saved everytime. So there is more factors playing on this show for others then in prashant. Just for EMON in last show, he got worst comment as copying of SONU, not perfect etc and Chang got the best comment but the result is as with you now. 3. If we count the regional voters, then nepalese is very much less than bengali for EMON, bihari for ANKITA, the northeastern people for AMIT etc. Except people in Darjeeling, Skim all nepalese went there for working, who is very very poor people in their backgournds in Nepal, I don't beleive they vote for Prashant or any other contestants. Recently I heard that the mobile network in Darjeeling and skkim is the poorest and just installed some years back which doesn't have much capacity to transfer big number sms in the same time. Beside that one sms cost Rs 3, I don't believe the average people sends 100s of sms everyweek with his own money. The people who has the capacity to send 1000s of sms has not time to react on idol things. With this reasons I don't believe he is in top 4 due to ethinic votes, I strongly feel he deserves, he has own style of singing at the time others are found to be copying others. And I do beleive he will win this title. GOOD DAY FOR ALL.
Read Full Discussion Thread for this article