I think so too gaunlebhai. I remember Prashant said he was happy that he got an opportunity to sing Sarfarosh's song. It seems the music director working with the contestants select the songs for each contestant rather than contestants pick his or her own songs. Knowing the facts that contestants cannot choose his or her own songs why the judges comments that the songs selection is not good or easy. I think judges are doing this just to let the certain contestants confidence down and boost the confidence for their favourite ones. The judges are playing poltics. These judges lack good judgements. I think they are not fit for judges.