Kirsten, I will be a little harsh, but take it with a grain of salt. Getting into grad school is not a tough task. The challenging task is to survive and more so to be able to live that grad school experience. The key to this is to find the right match. It doesnt need to be the one thats ranked #1 or #2. The goal in selecting a grad school should be "whats the place where I can grow the most in terms of social and professional attributes." You seem to have enough credentials to take you to any grad school of choice. I recommend you choose the one that will allow you to excercise your growth the most in all aspects. All my best, Email me if you need any further assistance.