Yes, I see, a similar thread was created before, and remember me posting. In this case, the guy is at no fault. He let her know that he wouldn't marry her and she still expected him to marry her. I do not feel sorry for her, why should we be sorry for her stupidity? So far I know the American culture, it is the place where people take words at their "gross value." When someone says no, they would mean it "no." Why she still thought that he would change his mind? Secondly, she should have done some research to find out about Muslim culture, she would know how it works in Muslim culture. Afterall, there are cases where people from South Asia do pretend to have fallen in love for some other reason, that would definitely be a sad story.