dude..if you are talking about brothers in arms 2005- directed by jean clauda then it's one of the worst movies ever....This movie owes 85 mins of my life..... The thin red line (7.2/10)....Good movie....Platoon(8.1/10)......Very very good movie....saving private ryan(8.3/10).....Great movie... So, saving private ryan beats platoon by a very narrow margin of .2