Posted by: Nepe January 25, 2006
Ashu, Nepe, and Arrow
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?        
Although mathematical models go over my head, it's good to see Sajhaites making sense of them and explaining things for us. I will be checking for more discussions. *** *** *** *** *** Meanwhile, I have been quietly enjoying the publicity ND Google group is getting from Ashu's critical remarks about it in this and other threads. As they say, no publicity is a bad publicity. Because, at the end of the day, people make their own opinion. Now, how's a publicity good for a group which loves, ahem, privacy ? Well, one, to attract more (of course like minded) people to it and, two, for members like me who want at least a partial transparency in it, to make a stronger case. So, I would thank Ashu for his contribution even when he is making assumptions and arguing about them. *** *** *** *** *** However, I am a bit disappointed to see that Ashu did not catch the drift of the original story (of Bhasmashur and boon) Gokul-jee brought so befitting to the discussion on how democratic a democracy can/should be. Can a system allow a component that kills the system ? Should a democracy include a voice for a dictatorship as a dissenting voice ? How can a voice for a dictatorship be a dissenting voice ? How can the supporters of Feb 1 claim a room in the house built to oppose it ? Or a supporter of the supporter of Feb 1, or a supporter of the supporters of the supporters of Feb 1 and so on, to be more inclusive. I think these were the questions. *** *** *** *** *** Zalim wrote: >Okay getting back to the original question...is democracy always the right solution? No, it is not always the RIGHT solution. However, it is always the BEST solution. Nepe
Read Full Discussion Thread for this article