← Back to Kurakani

Neapli Prostitutes meet in Butwal

Original Post

the prostitutes in Nepal meet in Butwal, demanding to legalize the sex trade. 1300 of them from 12 districts Huuummm Listen bbc.co.uk/nepali

shirish
Jun 7, 2005 8:26 AM · 39,763 views
18 Replies
Hushpuppy Jun 7, 2005 10:44 AM
hahhahaa...this is known as heights of umemployment..what KG doing about it?? Maybe some of them can pretty for PP.
shirish Jun 7, 2005 10:52 AM
They dont sound like unemplyed.....may be should check for cobwebs in their area of interest.
hancyguy Jun 7, 2005 11:10 AM
Sounds awakrd in nepal. But I think legalizing it solvs a lot of problems like unwanted marriage, repression from state, and more importantly a reliable source of national income. we don't know the underground economy of sex trade in nepal.
nepalean Jun 7, 2005 3:54 PM
xxx dude, sorry for your knowledge. Trafficking of woman is not done by the particular cast but some ill minded people are involved in this case and taking as a profession. If you go through the statistical data, most woman are mongol, thats true but mostly they are taken by their relatives. It is true that most trafficked gals are uneducated but history tells that gals from even high class family and highly educated are also being trafficked. So the problem is not created by certain cast but by lope hole of the law. Also nepali gals mostly trust their relatives. This is the next main reason tht our nepali sisters are being sold to the prostitution industry. This is shame of whole nepali ( male and female - female are also involed in this case). This problem is not created by certain cast but it is created by ( certain part of) culture, law and society.
moneyminded Jun 7, 2005 10:34 PM
mu...................jii..............haru yeta garyo uta garyo khali chettri bahun ko tauko maa................mula tamag, magar, gurung haru le cheli beti becheko samchar suneko chaina............these kind of ill minded ppl dont have any relegion, caste or country. wake up dude
locum Jun 8, 2005 7:43 AM
oho bahun haru le ta sabai cheli bigare lets kill all the brahmins while we are at it,why not all the chettris as well? we will get rid of all prossies,crime ,unemployment and then live happily after
raayann Jun 8, 2005 7:43 AM
hey xxx wats on your mind...........shit ??? " maanchhe pugi sakyo juunma (moonma)timi jasto haru ajhai aafno dhunma" kati jana aayo yo sajhama jaatiyeta ko kura garne tarr khai ahile uniharu??? shayed xxx lai thaha chhain uniharulai sajhaite le tin thatayera lakheteko bhanne.
rajankhanal Jun 8, 2005 8:03 AM
Raayann, I think you are stating quite correctly "maanchhe pugi sakyo juunma (moonma)timi jasto haru ajhai aafno dhunma", but only lacking on you is to have deep insight analysis of the existing siituation of Nepalese societies. You know that is the reality ground of Nepalese development context. We might think about the silicon valley in Kathmandu, but when you reach out of certain hundreds KM out of valley or district headquarter, the matter to talk about going to moon is not relevant than the deep rooted noxious structure and feudal system. I don't argue with you, if you are familiar than me in rural development issues of Nepal. We shouldn't ignore and shouldn't be afraid to discuss openly about the Caste System and existing deep roooted social complexcity. In any development agenda it should be an agenda, otherwise the opressed groups and the backwarded groups always remain back. I think the reality can be experienced in the remote villages, but not in Cities or nor in overseas. The discourse of Caste System shouldn't be brought as who are good and who are bad, but in a constructive means and views so that every body can be benefited with the discussion. I suggest if you all like to keep this discussion hot, lets go the XXX original posting on "The Brahmin Stranglehold over Nepal". This thread so far is for the issues of our the professional women of Nepal. I am really proud to hear that the Nepalese prostitute group could unite themselves and voice their need, which, so called the literate and so called "Thinktanks" of Nepal are afraid to discuss publically, at least not in favour of these women. Respect to those women's initiation, great!
realitysucks Jun 8, 2005 9:18 AM
I think xxx wants to bring up the issue of race because, either he/she is totally frustrated with the Brahmins or he/she is a racist. I think the issue of prostitution has nothing to do with Brahmins as a race but more to do with the actual criminals. You can?t put blame on a whole race an exclude criminals from other races. It is easy to point a finger at a race but let?s hear all the facts and names of the criminals. I am sure dalits are among the criminals too. And let?s not blame all for the crime of few. Yo ta yesto bhayo, kaam garne rame dosh paune shayme
rajankhanal Jun 8, 2005 9:31 AM
Hi realitysucks, I don't find any racist issue with XXX posting. The prosittution problem in our country is not the result of Caste System, but it is social problem we donot exploit (leagalize) like Thailand, India and other Western countries. I am repeating once again that it is not wise at all to mention that one group is more criminal than other or one is more powerful than other. These are cheap blames and puffing. It is not the intention of analysing the pros and cons of caste system in Nepal. We have to look the caste system in holistic approach than one or two incidence.
mahabahun Jun 10, 2005 1:22 PM
Khanal is the only person here who is even bothering to think. It is very easy to blame everything on the caste system, and especially on the Brahmins since they are in many respects superior. It makes no sense to blame prostitution on the Brahmins since they uphold the highest moral values and have done so for over 6000 years. Any Brahmin who visits prostitutes has forsaken the privileges granted to him or her by the Almighty and does not deserve to be called a Brahmin. Such a person becomes an outcaste and a criminal, there is no doubt about this because this is what the Shastras have said. This whole idea of some type of "openess" helping the situation is utterly misguided. By accepting prostitution, one only encourages it. Sometimes the best way to be compassionate is to take a fierce approach and here it is absolute neccesary that we completely cut down prostitution. Then only, will these people seek more wholesome and respectable jobs (hopefully with a pension plan). Those who say otherwise are narrow-minded and do not think of the future.
Pade_Queen_no.1 Jun 10, 2005 8:31 PM
Mahabahun, prostitution is the world's oldest profession. So no one can uproot it. It will go only when the human race will become extinct.
mahabahun Jun 11, 2005 3:18 AM
Padequeen, The same is true of murder, it has been present as long as the human race; by your logic, we should stop all efforts against murder because it will only go when the human race goes. Just as murder can be reduced with proper measures, so can prostitution. Just because every last person cannot be helped, it doesn't mean we should not help anyone at all. Please think more deeply next time.
rajankhanal Jun 11, 2005 4:44 AM
Mahabahun has very appreciative analysis! Great! I agree with you.
DC_Girl Jun 11, 2005 12:59 PM
"It is very easy to blame everything on the caste system, and especially on the Brahmins since they are in many respects superior. It makes no sense to blame prostitution on the Brahmins since they uphold the highest moral values and have done so for over 6000 years". Bahunbad again. what makes brahmins superior? and where did you get that they uphold the highest moral values? this is the very reason, this religion being forced into people's minds to drift them away from more important things in life, which is partly contributing to underdevelopment in the third world. if you look at the history of nepal, religion is very much politicized, and brahmins and shahs are to be blamed the most for keeping ppl misguided under the illusion of religion and orthodox rules.
pisces Jun 11, 2005 2:59 PM
This is what the root cause of deterioting situation of Nepal..Hatred against race and caste. I dont think Nepal and Nepali will ever goin to change.
mahabahun Jun 12, 2005 2:27 AM
"Bahunbad again. what makes brahmins superior? and where did you get that they uphold the highest moral values? this is the very reason, this religion being forced into people's minds to drift them away from more important things in life, which is partly contributing to underdevelopment in the third world. if you look at the history of nepal, religion is very much politicized, and brahmins and shahs are to be blamed the most for keeping ppl misguided under the illusion of religion and orthodox rules." When I say Brahmins are superior, I merely mean that they are generally higher in rank, station or authority. This is actually the primary meaning of the word "superior" (check a dictionary). Without religion, there is no free wil. Understand that the scientific and non-religious views of the world (with a few exceptions) hold that our decisions are based on a perfectly predictable series of collisions and interactions between brain particles. According to this position, there is no free will. If you think that by subscribing to such a flawed and fatalistic worldview people will be better off, then I think most people will disagree with you. Also keep in mind that all so-called "secular" values are actually ones that come from religion. You can claim they are universal but they never existed prior to religion and generally don't exist for many generations outside of religion. Religion has never been a problem for development, this is a myth perpetrated by Marxists and materialists. Most of the wealthier countries in the world are actually not secular. The only ones that are secular tend to be those without a long religious history like Nepal's. Religion is very politicized but it can hardly be said that it is by the Brahmins (in Nepal). People claim to be against the caste system but they are invariably against Brahmins. Thats okay, we are taught to be tolerant but we also have to correct your misconceptions. Most of the official religious ceremonies in Nepal are conducted by non-Brahmins, even the Hindu the ones. Nepali Brahmins have never been strict about this kind of matter. What you don't get is that the caste system is the oldest system that seperates church and state. In Nepal, this is the case and Brahmins basically had no real influence on government until the democracy came about (and it came about mostly because of Brahmins). In those ten years, there was more progress than in hundreds of years before it. Its in fashion to blame the Brahmins for everything but in Nepal its actually the Newars that are far more rigid about this. For instance, only Sakyas and Bajracaryas can recieved anuttarayogatantra initiation. In Buddhist tantras it is said that in this age, these are basically the only teachings that are likely to lead to liberation. This means that in their religion only a elite few can reach liberation and so on. This aside from the fact that it is Buddhist doctrine that only Buddhists can attain liberation. And what have the Brahmins said? We have said that all true paths lead to liberation, it doesn't matter who you were born as, what religion, etc... This kind of openess exists nowhere else - it is a tradition of tolerance that has been misconstrued by fundamentalist secularists.
mahabahun Jun 12, 2005 2:28 AM
"This is what the root cause of deterioting situation of Nepal..Hatred against race and caste." Most of the hatred is against Brahmins.
Login to join the conversation.

You might be interested in...

Latest Kurakani View all
Recent Classifieds View all
Upcoming Events View all
Service Providers View all
Ask Sajha AI Assistant