Hybrid  :)

mukurdhom · Jan 20, 2012 10:51 AM

i have follow up question: bau ghoda ama gadha bhayo bhane tyasko bacha k jaat ko huncha? bau sadey ama bhaisi bhayo bhane tyasko bacha kun jaat ko huncha? bau matarkosa ama bhatmas bhayo bhane tyasko biruwa k jaat ko huncha? bau kaley ama gori bhayo bhane tyo bacha k jaat ko huncha? bau joker ama nokar bhayo bhane bacho k huncha? to be continued....

chaurey · Jan 20, 2012 11:21 AM

 I think the kids will be labelled 'chhetri'. Based on what i know, when a Brahmin marries somebody of lower his/her kids will be move a step down. I dont really agree with this and that what i think. I might be wrong!!

busenitz · Jan 20, 2012 11:30 AM

so theres bramhin chettri and then newar as a whole?

patan · Jan 20, 2012 11:50 AM

मेरो बिचारमा त्यसको जात Hyena हुनुपर्छ. यी बाहुन छेत्री भनेकै Hyena  जस्तै त होनी i.e. Take benefit from somebody's effort.

dhoti_prasad · Jan 20, 2012 12:54 PM

 Why does it matter, though? 

footyfan · Jan 20, 2012 12:59 PM

busenitz, where did you hear that? Chhetri is a caste in itself not a mix-caste. Bahun+Chhetri is K.C. Not sure what bahun+newar would be, but I like Chaurey's question. That's more meaningful.

Kiddo · Jan 20, 2012 1:01 PM

I have seen cases but i am not a pundit on it. Well What i think is "two ppl from different castes get married and their progeny will be of the  lower caste (among them). If one of them is Brahmin, then they will be Chhetri (which is considered one step down than initial Brahmin caste)." The  whole point of caste system is to classify ppl on a ladder system (not talking about historically) so the supriority and inferiority does exist. I agree Chhteri is a caste itself but it isone step down to Brahmins. If Brahmins did something unethical, as a punishment they are moved down. There are no castes like G.C, K.C instead they are the surname of "Chhetri" caste.  p.s~ not to confuse you guys, I am not advocating the superiority or inferiority of any caste but just sharing my thoughts and opinion. I personally do not care about the caste but it will be nice understand the underlying theories.

busenitz · Jan 20, 2012 1:25 PM

 Chhetri is a  caste. 

footyfan · Jan 20, 2012 1:36 PM

Busentiz, I am not sure where you got the idea that Chhetri was a caste created out of moving Brahmins one caste down as punishment. Either I have got the fact wrong or you are making something without any basis. Like we have said here in the post, Chhetri is a stand alone caste not a derivative of Bahun/Brahmin. The class system in caste system existed to separate the labor and socio/economic structure of the ancient time. Brahmin obviously got the highest order because they wrote the book on caste system. Chhetris were the warrior clan, derivatives of which are Khas and Thakuris. You clearly are not familiar with the historical scriptures, so let's discuss something you are familiar with, Mahabharata. All those Pandavas and Kauravas, the kings, they were all chhetriyas. They didn't get that caste because their ancestors did something wrong. Brahmins worked for them, although they had to touch their feet. Some might find this dicussion futile; but we aren't advocating for caste system here; merely pointing out a fact on historical origins of an important aspect of our then society: caste system.

Kiddo · Jan 20, 2012 1:57 PM

 @ dhoti-prasad tero gf or budi lai bahun chhetri le bhyaidiyo ki kyaho ha?? ki tero aama lai nai ...??? Tero khas jaat ke ho bhan ta ani ko chai rahecha hyena kura garaula....Paji khate @ thread initiator The caste is chhetri, sadly. But how come it is chhetri? the child is half newar and half bahun. IS chhetri mixture of any other castes or chhetri itself a pure caste ? Fu....((k  those pandit bajes who made chhetri a dumpster to dump their mess. 

gorkhecowboy · Jan 20, 2012 1:57 PM

As long as we are talking about historical facts, may I ask, who went ahead and decreed that Newars are inferior to Bahuns?  Are Newars mentioned in scriptures as those of lower caste or even mentioned at all?

Nepali_American · Jan 20, 2012 2:17 PM

@ nepali-american You are right. bahuns claimed themselves to be the highest caste. They just cared about their own genetic purity and made others genetically messed up (which is good though) . See how strange is nepalese caste system......  Chhetri mom + bahun dad == chhetri child (50% chhetri genetically) Other caste mom + Bahun dad = chhetri child (0% chhetri genetically) how can this combination be a chhetri? I am 100% chhetri and my ancestor were not degraded from bahun.

gorkhecowboy · Jan 20, 2012 2:37 PM

@Nepali_American From what I know, you really have to look at which origin do you want to follow. The 4 caste system prevalent in hindu religion doesn't specify Newar into one single category as far as I know. Now, if you look at Muluki Ain (By Janga Bahadur) I believe there is a mention of Newar brahmin which fall into second class. Muluki ain puts Chhetri and Brahmins (those who wear janais) in first class. I want to quote Bhanu Bhakta here to remind what we're talking about after all is said and done: Chhetri ko chhoro tyo pau chunchha, ghina le chhudaina Manisa thulo dila le hunchha, jata le hudaina.

Kiddo · Jan 20, 2012 2:40 PM

I haven't posted here in a while but when people start talking like bahun and chettri are superior to others it just boils my blood. Those bahun and chettri's who haven't gotten over their supposed superiority need to be lined up in a row and butt fuqd. Even in this day and age they feel like they are superior to others, that just shows their stupidity.

shrestha babu · Jan 20, 2012 2:42 PM

 Quote from the originator "........Seriously asking........Life ko sabal cha yar.............lau na..........  " Dude if your life depends on such a petty thing, then I think it's already effed up.

jay-z · Jan 20, 2012 2:47 PM

 Kiddo, I never said Chhetri is not a caste. Yes, it is a caste but the caste system rely on superiority/inferiority. Look at the figure below I am not saying all Chhetris are "Chhetri" because they got moved down and once they were Brahmins. You didnt get my point. All I am saying is Brahmins were penalized for their  so called unethical behaviours by moving a step down. Lets assume a soocer game, if a player doesnot perform well on a game, the coach will put him on bench. But that doesnot mean all the players on the bench performed poor on the pitch and ended up on the bench.  I dont want to talk about who wrote the caste system and all that sort of stuffs but we all interpreted the scriptures wrong. What it said was there are four castes and they were classified as:   SUDRAS- A person who is self centered, doesnot care about anything else but him/her self VAISHYA- A person who thinks more than himself but limits to his family and goal of his/her life is material gain. (ppl doing business ) KSHATRIYA- A person whose goal is more than serving a family and serves his/her country (fighters, worriers,rulers) BRAHMINS- A person who has a higher goal of living by studying and understanding the scriptures and spreading knowldege. His/Her purpose of life is to gain spiritiual growth and share it.     Thats how it is mentioned and it says your life decides what caste you belong to. Since we believe in reincarnation, what we do today and how we choose to live will affect the caste we will be born in our next life. p.s~ I have shared my knowldge and information. I am not advocating for a particular caste. I may not believe all the things I wrote since i presented it based on religious and historical information.

busenitz · Jan 20, 2012 2:48 PM

@ kiddo Bhanubhakta le teti mitho kura kaile lekhechan? 

DalluKoSanu · Jan 20, 2012 2:48 PM

@busenitz Dude, I was going to quote what you had said earlier and then realized you already deleted those posts. It's all good, as long as you do not say "Kshatriya was a caste that came from Brahmins who did something wrong" I am okay with how you interpret it. Yes, I have already said it in my post that Brahmins were of the highest order in the hindu caste system (again because they wrote the book) and by Nepali muluki Ain they share it with Kshatriyas. They might have made sense back then to easily portionalize population into task specific group, they mostly kept our civilization from fostering and threw us backwards. @Shrestha Babu. You are what I call a blindfolded warrior. The warrior only hears what he wants to and comes swinging. As soon as he hears anybody talk about caste OR anything related to India, he comes and waves his sword up high like a proud warrior. Fact is none of the previous poster (including busenitz) have claimed bias on caste, we are merely pointing out the historical facts. In case you were referring it in general (not to the posters) then I agree with you.

Kiddo · Jan 20, 2012 3:06 PM

busenitz are you seriously posting that pyramid around like it's the god given truth that you believe in?

bad boy · Jan 20, 2012 3:06 PM

हैन अहिलेको जमानामा पनि छेत्रीहरु छन् जो आफुलाई कालु पाण्डे नै थानछन् . छेत्रीहरुको बाउ भन्न लाएक श्री पांच ज्ञानेन्द्र लाइ त बाहुनहरुले पद बाट निस्कासित गरि सके . घैटोमा घाम लाग्ने कैले होला बाहुन सबै भन्दा ठुलो भए के राजा भन्दा नि ठुलो हो ? येस्ता जात पातको कुरा नगरे बेश हुन्छ

shrestha babu · Jan 20, 2012 3:17 PM

My knowledge says the kid will be chhetri but with fathers(bahun) caste.Thus come all these adhikari,lamichhane,Wagle, and so on 'chhetris'. They still differ from the pure chettris like Khadka,thapa,karki,basnet and so on.My grannys view.

shiva_linga · Jan 20, 2012 3:30 PM

www.cbc.ca/news/interactives/shafia-trial/

intelligentguy · Jan 20, 2012 3:32 PM

 Hey guys,    Let me clear it up. I didnt post the pyramid to prove the supremacy of a particualr caste but to explain a reason.  Kiddo, I dont know why you are acting offended when I said. I made myself clear and do not believe and support the whole system.  I dont care who wrote the caste system in the scriptures and who made Brahmin higher and Sudra lower. If you go by the scripture, there is no point for you be excited coz your brahmin or depressed coz your Sudra. 

busenitz · Jan 20, 2012 3:52 PM

Busenitz I am offended because I saw somebody posting a blatantly false statement. I am not a chhetri FYI and was definately not offended in that terms. All I did was point out a false statement which you already removed so end of discussion.

Kiddo · Jan 20, 2012 6:19 PM

he should be newar with last name of bahun. Like there are paudel chhetris, bhandari chettris who were degraded from bahuns. So kid should be paudel newar or bhandari newar or adhikari newar ( based on father's last name ). That was just guess, and another guess is Kid will be in next x-men movie. 

default061 · Jan 20, 2012 7:52 PM

 the answer is "Human".

anavon1090 · Jan 21, 2012 12:54 AM

Kaliya boro jaat ko problem solve bho ta ...? 8 years agadi ko post recha aba ta boro ko kids ko jaat ko probems suru huncha hola हे हे हे

pandeyji · Jan 29, 2021 3:19 AM

Traditionally your kid will be “jharra “ Chettri but more important than that he will be a human, no different than you and I and if given proper upbringing probably would be a better person than all of us here whose mind is still stuck on “jat bhat “ Seriously, if your life depends on jaat and not on how much you and your intended value and cherish each other, you have very rough days ahead.

chicagoan · Jan 29, 2021 8:16 AM

हिटलरले कहा बाट पायो त त्यो जातिय सुद्दिकरण गर्ने मन्त्र ? हाम्रा विद्वान महोदय एबम संस्कृत का महान ज्ञाताले उब्जाएको जाति भेद बाट होईन र ? ठिकै भन्नु भयो " पातकी हरुले सुद्दिकरण को नाम मा डमस्तरको सृजना गरि हालिएदिए उनका कुकृत्य हरु" अनि खत्रि छेत्री हुने बनाए ? एक जना भन्थे मुजी मेरो अघोरी बाउ चै सुद्द बाहुन रे म चै खत्री रे | खाना खान बस्दा कहिलै चित्त नबुझ्ने, जहिले पनि टाढा बसेर अछुत झैँ खानु पर्ने तेसैले यो सरिरमा मासु नथपिएको ( दुब्लो पातलो थियो) |

Logan · Jan 29, 2021 11:06 AM

kaliya bhai, Nepal ma haal samma ko chalan anusar tyo bacha ko thar KC (Khatri kshatri } hunchha .

tallagheremaila · Jan 29, 2021 4:53 PM