terobaje: be consistent what you say. above you said " Those judges will tell it as they hear, & they liked it a lot. shantipriya looks like you know a lot about music and melodies, even better than the professional judges." now the karma is eliminated you are saying "I dont think Indians want to see another Prashant Tamang or anyone with a Nepali origin winning this contest". which one is you?? anyone who knows even a "A" of  classical music or Music, can tell he is amongst the weakest candidate. The judges in saregama are very soft and in totality, they provide constructive criticism, unlike Annu Mallik, that is why they praised him, even today. So do not get carried away by their praise or criticism. I like music and I do not associate it with any NATIONALITY. 

shantipriya · Sep 11, 2010 8:30 PM

consistent? what do you mean? I stand by what I wrote. he is good singer hands down and that was proven when the judges praised him and now he is eliminated doenst mean that he is not a good singer. There are a lot of good singers in the competition and he got out, simple as it sounds, I think he did have the potential to win it all but he didnt so may the best singer win. My suggestion was a mere maybe he didnt get enough support in India being of Nepali origin. dont bother wasting your time dissecting my comments. NOW here we are trying to support a good singer who has made it to a very talented stage on his own accord, where his voice is also praised by all judges and listeners alike AND here you come along pointing out his vocal flaws like an expert, and then you even bloat about your classical music affiliation and yet go ahead to criticize well known proven Indian judges that they dont do their jobs, why are you going to teach them now? they by nature have to give constructive criticism by pointing the good and bad parts too. Here is what I dont see eye to eye with you. You seem to be stuck that he is a bad singer and his vocal has flaws, (now that seems fair) but you go an ahead analyzing how and where he has flaws and NOW he is out ,you are acting like an amateur smarty pants saying "SEE I TOLD YOU HE IS A BAD SINGER" im the expert and i told you so. AND I AM RIGHT go take vocal lessons karma. Music in my blood just mine."  Music is universal, I agree but I do love my Nepali music a bit more than other.

terobaaje · Sep 12, 2010 2:05 AM

Do not pass your immature comments about the field which you have ZERO idea. and when you lose accept that as a brave man not like a true coward, who always blames  others for their  defeat ( in this case you are blaming the judge). This is a competition which means you have to compete and need to be better than the rest, as simple as that. Btw, your whining make sense to me!

shantipriya · Sep 12, 2010 10:43 AM

shantipriya My credentials will shock your brains out. I dont brag around. Ya I have met people like you before. You have no answers to my comments and yet you counter with stupid remarks saying stuff that makes no sense to me.well this is what you want to hear. Yes you were right ok, you win, karma was terible singer, his nasel vocals and his lack of classical music knowledge led to his elimination. I cant believe that you saw it comming even before anyone. You must be very talenetd that you can hera better than anyone. Please teach me, do I qualify?? happy now shanti priya, here can you judge this?

terobaaje · Sep 12, 2010 2:52 PM

Heard lot of " Kothe singers" like this they come n go!

shantipriya · Sep 13, 2010 6:52 AM

Santipriya ko " kothi" ma yesta singer ta Kati aauchan Kati hoina muiyya... Yesta kothe singer hai

sna · Sep 13, 2010 9:17 AM

Now I REALLY have an Idea of the type of person you are shantipriya, You have no talent in the field of music, You are just NOBODY acting like somebody. You have NO music knowledge and thats what I had thought from the beginning of this tread , and this comment confirms my doubt.                                      Heard lot of " Kothe singers" like this they come n go!

terobaaje · Sep 13, 2010 9:38 AM

I do not think, sajha is a forum to prove your credential in a first place. It is a forum for your opinion. Based upon my knowledge I predicted " Karma Sherpa" will be eliminated soon, which turned out to be true, and this is the FACT. So I understand your frustration and feeling of defeat, again read my comments above about terobaje's contradictory logic..makes me laugh rather.. again you from the same mind set said "Yes you were right ok, you win, karma was terible singer, his nasel vocals and his lack of classical music knowledge led to his elimination. I cant believe that you saw it comming even before anyone."  I am not here to win or loose, nor I will gain anything from that. The fact that I was not biased in any respect unlike you, I predicted Karma will be eliminated soon " which you find hard to believe". Judges were not harsh in Saregamapa, so you did not see their acrid criticism, but they did evaluate. So you guys are free to presume and have your own conjecture about my knowledge of music. Does not matter to me.The fact is I do not see music as other than JUST MUSIC unlike you when a nepali face comes to sing you go euphoric. You must be among those who would have donated your dad's hard earned money for Prashant Tamang's Indian Idol's campaign, sorry I do not fall under that category, no offense, but this a personal choice. I do not even know what Prashant Tamang is doing for the sake of Nepal and nepali nor the story of Karma is any different, or would have been different even he had won the contest. I do not need to comedown to your level to prove my point. Your knowledge of music and musical sense is already proven  by Karma. Again if you want to learn music, first learn to respect the music just as a " music" irrespective of its nationality.

shantipriya · Sep 13, 2010 10:13 AM

Are you serious? just read your statement, you are saying that we cant accept defeat because of your correct prediction, and then you go on saying that you are here neither to win or loose. NOW SMARTA*SS  read this carefully, We are not competing here OK, you think Karma is a bad singer and we think he is a good one. simple as that NOTHING TO DO WITH THE CONTEST RESULTS. You dont like him? FINE move on. Im not interested in your analysis. There are thousands of great singers in this world without any classical training so beat it looser. WHY cant your dumb brains come to terms that all we are doing is supporting a good singer win or loose. No one asked for your opinion SO SHUT UP. Keep your high level to your self . If sajha is not good for your upper class attitude than Dont bother showing up here, By the way YOUR level is the lowest of the Lowest kind to insult peoples parents for the sake of proving a point. and you have the guts so say "NO OFFENSE" are you kidding me? Hey this conversation is over, You just showed your true color, a naive SOB who thinks the world goes only one way ,my way, the only way, and thats the right way. Im done here, Moral of this discussion, Dont play with sh*it, it will only stink more.

terobaaje · Sep 13, 2010 10:42 PM

Baje and priya, enough yar, just end the debate. You both r wasting time on bs.

furke · Sep 14, 2010 12:35 AM

your choice of words shows your true mentality and your poor upbringing! and right it is stinking...

shantipriya · Sep 14, 2010 8:33 AM