Nepe
Nov 27, 2004 11:28 AM
Ashu,
Good to hear from you. And I am glad to see you this much opened up regarding your view about the King. And I look forward to reading the column you are planning to write for Nepali papers and hopefully discussing about the things of my interest. I hope to see one of my criticisms about you that you are not opened-up about the King go away.
This posting, which looks like a sneak-peak of your future communications, clearly shows your faith in the King. I do not have any faith in the King and the royal family and their protectors- bhai-bhardars, old guards, new guards and the most powerful and most visible of all, the royal army. I think the large picture of our failed experiment with the monarchy-democracy hybrid, or rather a chimera, has, in it's heart, the loyalty of the Royal Army to the King. Your chintan-manan about democracy appears to be your personal interpretation of smallar pictures taking it's hybrid nature in Nepal as granted.
I hope to have more conversation with you on this in future.
Here are just quick reply to some of your points:
When political parties cannot decide what to do, thereby making space for the king to seize his opportunity to do as he pleases, you are against the king. Fine. But when Nepali academics start fighting with one another, asking the king to step in to "save Royal Nepal Academy (RNA)", you bend over backward to justify their action by saying that, well, that's cultural and not political.
I don't know how you synthesized this argument but it looks like an animal with a buffalo's horns and a goat's tail. Let's do one animal at a time. First the goat. Regarding the academy, as I said, 'Raja aau desh bachaau' and 'Raja aau Academy bachau' do not convey the same message. You appears to be insisting that they do. Clearly, you are guided by your positive political bias towards the King. Or alternatively, I am not as intelligent as you are, who is able to identify them as the same thing.
Now, the buffalo. In the first sentence above, you have said many interesting things which can be subjects for larger discussions. That for some other time. Here I will just point to how illogocal or rather reverse logical your logic is there.
If you are talking about post Asoj 17 scenario, yes, political parties have not been able to decide what to do.
However, before Asoj 17 they were making decisions one after another. At the point when the King, in your view, "seized his opportunity", they all had been able to unanimously decide what to do next.
They all unanimously and very very very strongly, so strongly that, they were ready even not to look if there is something in the constitution to come in their way, decided that Sher Bahadur Deuba will continue to run the government.
There was no space for the King, Okay there was space, but that was not the one created by the inability of the political parties to take decisions. The space was already there, although invisible and that to those who refuse to see it, long before we can blame the political parties for anything.
The space, that comfortable and unquestionable trustworthy space, was the LOYALTY of the army to the King. Had the army been or perceived as neutral, political parties could kick the ass of Gyanendra Sahu jee and tell him the sovereignty of Nepal is not his baauko birtaa anymore.
So gyanendra Sahu jee extended his real estate with the capital of army's loyalty. With his space extended even more, the political parties got sidelined more and more and became unable to take strong decisions.
This is my view. Ashu thinks the reverse.
But he seems not to have touched upon the invisible signs as of now. That is why you can chant anti-King slogans in Ratna Park and NOT get arrested like you did during Panchayati times.
One more time. To a wrong person, a wrong credit, taken away from from the right persons.
Those slogans are there not because of Raja's love to freedom. Those slognas are not there because of Raja's determination to nullify the law of the land that protects his family from being disgraced. Those slogans are there exclusively for the courage of our youth, their readiness for sacrifice for freedom and democracy. Ashu used to be never tired of ridiculing these youth until recently. And now he is thankful to the King.
Well, views aafno aafno, priority aafno aafno.
This presence of invisible right, to me, represents some hope, that the King is going half-way.
Again, dristikon aafno aafno. If this guy is going half-way, where the hell he was before, why the hell he came here in the first place. May be these questions are irrelevant to Ashu. To me , interpreting one step in isolation of the other is senseless and dishonest too.
Now, it's up to the parties to meet him half way too, and give Nepal a FRESH start by: (a) uniting against the Maoists, and (b) going for the elections, come hell or highwater.
Well, the unity of the King and the political parties is not the solution to the Maoist problem. In fact, that was what gave rise to and strengthened the Maoists. Itihas saakchhi chha.
The king may be a lot of things, be he is not stupid.
The King must be happy to be certified as not being a stupid by somebody like you. I don't want to debate on that. However, I'll say this much. No matter what, in the next political change, the King is going to lose all or most of the political power he had before. I am ready to bet anything on this. Would you like to bet, Ashu ?
In the next political change, hopefully not far away, we will find out if Gyanendra was a stupid or was a smart guy.
Astoo.