Posted by: nepalilaure September 30, 2011
Login in to Rate this Post:
0 
? 
?
Shantipriya,
You are comparing before and after 46. You know very few people would like to have an autocratic family rule in Nepal like before 2046, even Kamal Thapa is advocating for a Constitutional Monarchy. If you go back to 2046, some people would say, why 2046? why not go back to 2036, as many people recall how panchayat won the 36 election.
If i can, i want to go back to the Friday a Decade ago when Durbar Massacre happened, and stay there forever, i mean politically. That is an unsolved incident which many people suspect a foreign power (India) had a major role to play as a mastermind (?). So, at least I wont be ready to accept Gynandra is more patriot as you have mentioned in your earlier post unless we get negative test result on the involvement of foreign power and the people inside the palace.
Is Federalism good or bad for a country like Nepal is a very normative question, i agree that we never reach to a conclusion on this issue. But, since we already have a constituent assembly that will hopefully give a constitution with a federal structure , I believe there is enough room to be optimistic that federalism will make the country stronger given the representation of people from all the regions. If you fail to give your citizen a hope that Kathmandu is there in your need, then they may try to look for an alternative.
You are comparing before and after 46. You know very few people would like to have an autocratic family rule in Nepal like before 2046, even Kamal Thapa is advocating for a Constitutional Monarchy. If you go back to 2046, some people would say, why 2046? why not go back to 2036, as many people recall how panchayat won the 36 election.
If i can, i want to go back to the Friday a Decade ago when Durbar Massacre happened, and stay there forever, i mean politically. That is an unsolved incident which many people suspect a foreign power (India) had a major role to play as a mastermind (?). So, at least I wont be ready to accept Gynandra is more patriot as you have mentioned in your earlier post unless we get negative test result on the involvement of foreign power and the people inside the palace.
Is Federalism good or bad for a country like Nepal is a very normative question, i agree that we never reach to a conclusion on this issue. But, since we already have a constituent assembly that will hopefully give a constitution with a federal structure , I believe there is enough room to be optimistic that federalism will make the country stronger given the representation of people from all the regions. If you fail to give your citizen a hope that Kathmandu is there in your need, then they may try to look for an alternative.