Homeyji,
here I'm pointing out your previous post just above mine.
that's where exactly I'm glued. I'm analyzing the story from Roshan's point of view. I want to be lil' liberal here, at least he can imagine what he had wished for. But yes, Stiffler is cent percent correct. Writer has rights to present story whatever way he wants and that's the meditative one, that way writer does not care about readers. He even does not care whether readers will agree on his point or not. He just contemplate over his expression. Since I'm a lover, I would like to view from Roshan's point of view.