The starter of the thread spoke my mind.... i was gonna say that myself.......I have Zee TV at home since some years...I also watched the challenge 2005 and since then I agree that Sa re ga ma pa is 100 times better than Indian Idol. The finalists of 2005 Vinit Debojit and Hema were gr8 singers... Talking abt II 3, only 2 singers in the finals Amit and Emon deserve to be real playback singers, prashant and Chang have got good voice but they are so so.... all the sa re ga ma finalists are as good as one another...u cannot tell which one of these is the best...they all deserve to be #1. 1. Amanat 2. Aneak 3. Musarrat 4. Poonam 5. Raja even Junaid and Sumedha are better than II3 finalists... so cheer for sa re ga ma pa... Like someone said, i watch I.I. only to watch prashant sing..