Yes it was "yeh jo des hai tera" that I was talking about and nope, he didn't nail it for me. The emotion that you feel in A.R Rehman's rendition was almost non-existent. Patriotic songs should touch your heart first and your ear second. As I said in one of my previous posts, he sounded very mechanical.

I would also like to disagree that Amit is more versatile than any other contestant there(well let's ignore Ankita. She doesn't count). The two of his most memorable performances are "nasha ye pyar ka nasha" and "pehla nasha" and both are soft, soothing romantic numbers by Udit. The rest of his performances range from good to average to bad.
If a few amazing performances decide the greatness of a singer then i'm afraid every contestant is out of the world there. Even Chang has had a few great performances.

By overrated, I do not mean to say that Amit is a bad singer. He is indeed a good singer, but what really irks me is that judges are very easy on him..