Why do I think Amit is overrated? Hmm I have quite a few reasons actually.
His performance today was farrr from being perfect- like Udit TRIED to point out.Was he good? Sure. But was he as great as Anu Malike keep saying? I don't think so.
Fortunately(for him) his weaknesses are usually easily ignored whereas the same mistake by Prashant, Puja and you would see JA and AM pounce on them with their sur-taals' microscopes.

He sang "Nasha yeh pyar ka Nasha" brilliantly. Judges went all crazy over him and so did people. And I strongly believe that he's still benefitting from it. The other day, he sang "Omkara" and messed it up. He forgot lyrics, he messed up his sur and sang the entire song without giving the right feel to it. Illa Arun and Udit again tried to speak about it, but AM didn't even let them finish their sentences.

I forgot the song that he sang on Independence day.Judges did criticise him to an extent for that performance, but not without lacing it with some beautiful words(hence confusing the viewers)

He is a good singer no doubt, but I do not buy all the praises that he gets everytime-regardless of how he sings. Even before he performs, you know what the judges have to say. Judges(barring udit) are not ready to accept that he falters too. His shortcomings are ignored rather conveniently and that's what makes him Overrated.