If the judges thought her voice was childish, they shouldn't have selected her at all. But they did, and then bashed her at every episodes after that. And i think Indian Idol should be more than just a search for a playback singer. If India is just going to get an average playback singer through a nation wide contest, then Indian Idol is just a hype. I think the search should be for an exception talent in the field of music. It isnt necessary ttat he/she be a playback singer. It take it as a shame that the search is for just another Udit or Sonu Nigam.