SexyDeuta, I think you don't have much sangeet gyan by saying Prashant is 5 times better than Amanat Ali. Prashant is a pretty good singer compared with other Indian Idol contestants, but have you even watched Saragemapa? Those guys are learned singers and they even sing better than the current playback singers. In that song alone, Prashant cannot be compared with Amanat Ali. Amanat Ali is learned singer. He stays with the Sur, and taal. You know how hard that is, especially while performing live? Those two cannot be compared. Indian Idol is a performance show and the judgement is based on how satisfied the crowd and the judges are. Saragema is based on pure music and singing talent, not some performance gimmick. You cannot compare apples with oranges. That said, I give all the best to Prashant. Although this is the first time I've watched him sing, Seeing him give such a good performance without actually taking music lessons, and having difficulties with accent, I give kudos to him!!.