Any state is good for students as long as they complete the objective that they came here with (to finish up a degree with an above average GPA and find a job). BTW, NY is not bad in the sense 'that off the books' jobs are abundantly available and students could work their azzes off even during the school year! However, the atmosphere for attending colleges here is very unlike other places (too much social-events/partying and extra-curricular activities...if you know what I mean). Many end up dropping out!