I agree with Gyanguru this time.But my logic of taking either of them is different.For opening spell,undoubtedly,there are Jahir and Munaf.Chosing Pathan means giving depth to batting line up as well and his bowling is as good as agarkar(may be even better when in firm) and Indian can not afford to play with four medium/fast pacer.In this scenario,either one of them will be chosen for number 8.And if they opt to chose Pathan,they can even send them up the order(as you said)....