Slack I also made the same mistake. I thought 1 goat=1 chicken+ 1 dog. However, I don't think the question was phrased wrong. It just wasn't phrased optimally. 1 goat=1 chicken + 1 dog, only when the dog never belonged to Rambo. He clearly said, he will give Shyambo ONE OF HIS DOG. If he is giving one of his dog, then that dog has to be subtracted from his account. Let's move on.