If all critiques are to be written only by subject matter scholars, all articles would be as dumb and dull as a scientific journal article. I had practically stopped reading Environ Sci Technicol., J Contam Hodrol., and Langmuir beginning the day my graduate thesis was approved. Still I continue to be an avid reader. So, I opine Anup has done a very good job of penning his observations on Nepali Music, and I endorse it a worth read. However, to reiterate, this is my opinion.