hoe credible is this website?
.
has this been verified by any other news site?
http://www.mysansar.com/?p=323
(for those who prefer to remain ignorant about nepali unicode, the report says that the security forces in surkhet basically rebelled against g's mandate, and issued a statement to the effect that they 'are sorry we interfered in the protests, we are soldiers of the country and not g's slaves, we will not stop you anymore
verbatim:
शान्तिपूर्ण आन्दोलन दबाउन जतिसुकै निर्मम आदेश आए पनि अब पड्कने बन्दुकहरु लोकतन्त्रको विरुद्ध नभइ लोकतन्त्रको पक्षमा पड्कने छन्। आम नेपाली जनताको चाहनाभन्दा हामी बाहिर हुने छैनौं ।
how credible is this report and this website?
if it is true, watch for a domino effect as other garrisions revolt as well, with only those troops whose commanders are utterly loyal to g sticking to his side
my my my, what a turn of events no?'
I don't think so...... There are many many people behind that web site.
.
yeah, ive been following this website and so far it hasnt led me astray
its just that this particular item has been posted for over 12 hours on this site yet no mainstream news network seems to have picked it up and verified it
hence the worry that this might just be rumor
we know that ekantipur aint all that speedy, but 12 hours seems a long long time for such significant news, even for kantipur
and this would something they would absolutely jump on, were it proven to be fact
Just to let you know, Umesh Ji doesn't buy news from agency like AP, xinuaha or Reuters. He has many friends and well-wishers all around the kingdom.Since, everyone know he looks after this website personally or may be with the help of few friends as claimed by karmarana. So, he gets the news from all aorund the kingdom from his friends or other bloggers or journalist or may be even relatives. And I believe this channel has been really instrumental in dissipating the news.
well someone might doubt the credibility of the news, as raised appropriately by le chef ... but i think at this hour of agitation no one is in a mood to spread the propangada. This above example of security personnel refusing to go against the Nepalese people is just one Chord you've heard in UNISON.....we will definitely have many melody to follw
www.mysansar.com is good website for many people living outside of nepal. However I have heard from some people who know Mr Umesh that he's one big opportunist. I would think twice before i put my full trust in this person. No offence.
Umesh is the most credible on news about Nepal now.
Now I can also say how credible are the people who said that Mr. Umesh opportunist to Bhatbhateni?
Guys we need to trust eachother right now otherwise Mandelas will take chance against us. Now that is what i will call Opportuni..........
.hmm, with regards to merosansar... to begin with, he the blogger says "यो पत्र सुर्खेतका सुरक्षाकर्मीले लेखेको दावी गरिएको छ। " so that means he is not claiming this to be 100% true but just that
"पत्र शनिवार वीरेन्द्रनगरमा आयोजित कोणसभामा उद्योग वाणिज्य संघ सुर्खेतका अध्यक्ष सूर्यबहादुर खड्काले सार्वजनिक गर्नुभएको थियो। अध्यक्ष खड्काले सो पत्र सुरक्षाकर्मीले आएर दिएको दावी गर्नुभएको तर जिल्ला प्रहरी कार्यालयका एस.पी. योगन्द्रबहादुर कटुवालले आफू मातहतका निकाय र सुरक्षाकर्मीबाट यस्तो पत्र प्रेषित नभएको ठोकुवा गर्नु भएको छ भने शाही नेपाली सेना र सशस्त्र प्रहरीबाट हालसम्म कुनै प्रतिक्रिया आएको छैन भनी स्वतन्त्र समाचार सेवाको समाचारमा उल्लेख छ।"
all we know is a certain person read this letter out loud and he (not merosansar) claims this is true. so this is less of an issue of trusting merosansar.
the quesiton of authenticity of the letter, however, is a completely different matter.
mysansar ko sattama merosansar bhaye dherai ramro hunthyo
go to the site below
www.pokharacity.com/online_news/index.htm
this site is covering about the authenticity of the letter written by surakshyakarmi.
mysansar.com is quite credible and independent so far. There was a video blog which highlighted the humanly and descent behaviour of an Army officer to the demonstrators and Umesh wrote about it as he saw it. Umesh ji deserves an applaud for this and so does the Army officer appearing in the video.
I think he is doing quite a good job..I appreciate the way he uploads any events instantly..like the video of royal proclaimation...it was there when no other site cud even upload what was said.
We dont know him personally so lets not get baised by other's perception , we gotta think about the credibility of other's perception too...Professionally he is superb, look at his hard work..at one moment he is taking footage of curfew affected area risking himself being in the middle of trouble and on the other hand he uploads it in no time...this is real dedication of his work.... yess he deserves a BRAVO.
.Umesh is doing a great job. Some of his article says that it is not 100% sure, however there are many videos and audio in his web and I think those are 100% true, coz cameras don't lie. I admire his courage and appreciate the job he is doing.
Merosansar is a one sided reporter.
At this junction of the revolution, the Maoist attack at Chautara is very significant but merosansar didn't even have one single word to say about it. It is being ignored as if it means nothing.
The rule of the maoist gun is not that far. The Nepali janata are sheeps who will just follow anyone who leads no questions asked.
At one time before this whole movement became big, I once asked few questions in merosansar which was contrary to the bloggers writings. And unfortunately, for someone fighting for a free democratic cause, my posting was deleted right away since it conflicted with his one sided reporting.
In the new Nepal, we need more reporters who report about both sides of the coin.
Yeah, any comment posted in his web blog that may raise a question about him, he removes immediately.. he cannot take up the criticism. That means he is doing propaganda !!!! One-sided means propoganda.
.lop-sided he is, but i don't think it is propaganda. to be propaganda, there has to be untruths there, which i don't see. by the way, he is not absolutely one-sided - he does have a video clip where he praises the army guy who lets the protestors go.
btw, here is something for nyuser:
अपडेट (मध्यान्ह 1215) सिन्धुपाल्चोकका सरकारी कार्यालयहरुमा हिजो राति एकैसाथ गरिएको आक्रमणमा मारिनेमा एक जना सर्वसाधारण भक्तबहादुर श्रेष्ठ, १ सैनिक अनि कम्तीमा चार माअोवादी मारिएका छन्। भिडन्तमा स्थानीय बासिन्दाको घरमा पनि क्षति पुगेको छ। आक्रमणको क्रममा जिल्ला अस्पताल पनि ध्वस्त भएको छ। अस्पतालमा भएका ११ बिरामी पनि गोलीको छर्राले घाइते भएका छन्। घाइतेमध्ये ३ गम्भीर छन् र आज बिहान सेनाले काठमाडौं ल्याएको छ। अस्पतालभित्रै पनि बम, रगत ध्वंश छ। त्यहाँ आज दिनभर कर्फ्यु लगाइएको छ। क्षेत्र कोलाहलपूर्ण र त्रस्त छ। माअोवादीतर्फ ठूलो क्षति भएको अनुमान गरिएको छ। शान्तिपूर्ण आन्दोलन चर्किरहेको बेला देशभर युध्दविराम नगरी अस्पतालका बिरामीसमेत घाइते हुने गरेर आक्रमण गरी माअोवादीले ठूलो गल्ती गरेको छ। यो उनीहरुकै लागि प्रत्युत्पादक हुने निश्चित छ।
-
http://www.mysansar.com/?p=324#more-324
अपडेट (बिहान 1115) हिजो सिन्धुपाल्चोक सदरमुकाम चौतारामा भएको माअोवादी आक्रमणमा एक सैनिक मारिएको र ६-७ जना घाइते भएको रक्षा मन्त्रालयले पुष्टि गरेको छ। एक सर्वसाधारणसहित कम्तीमा ५ जनाको मृत्यु भएको छ। थप विवरण आउन बाँकी छ। भिडन्त बिहान २ बजेसम्म जारी रहेको बताइएको छ। उता, नेपाल वन टेलिभिजनका दुई पत्रकार तिलक कोइराला र जनक पण्डितलाई हिजो साँझ डिल्लीबजारमा सुरक्षाकर्मीहरुले पत्रकारहरुले नकारात्मक कुरामात्रै दिन्छन् भन्दै कुटपिट गरेको पत्रकार महासंघले जनाएको छ। कोइरालाको मोडल अस्पतालमा उपचार भइरहेको छ भने पण्डित उपचारपछि घर फर्किसकेका छन्।
अपडेट (राति 10:13) : देशभर शान्तिपूर्ण जनआन्दोलन चर्किरहेको बेलामा माअोवादीले सिन्धुपाल्चोकको सदरमुकाम चौतारामा आक्रमण गरेर बेफ्वाँकमा आफ्नो उपस्थिति देखाउने प्रयास गरेको छ। अहिले दोहोरो भिडन्त जारी रहेको छ भन्ने खबर प्राप्त भएको छ। थप विवरण आएको छैन। सुरक्षा निकायले भने आक्रमणको पुष्टि गरेको बुझिएको छ।
-
http://mysansar.com/
I think he is doing a good job. He is an Amature Journalist. He has warm blood, he is sharp on his criticism. He is not mature enough, by showing his Name and Address, his picture he is exposing himself to a lot of Danger. He is likely to face a lot of danger if he gets any kind of attention from the government.
I was shocked by his comments "Shree panch lai shree tin, Shree tin lai shree ek lounuparcha'. Well I believe he is welcoming a lot of danger to himself if he stands like this. He should take control on what he says because he is picking up a lot of attention in the net.
Well wish him, all the best and suggest him to watch his back. Warm blood is good for Journolism, the updates he posts are excellent.
Please log in to reply to this post
You can also log in using your Facebook
